The wildest BAYC narrative of the past couple of days: “Machi keeps selling monkeys, but the floor price has held steady—which shows demand is really strong 🦍”
Bro, take a look at the prices he’s selling them for.
On-chain blogger OnchainLens dug up the records:
#32 bought one for 105 ETH back in the day and sold it for 12.5 ETH;
#4069 47 bought for 9.5 and sold;
#9770 36 bought for 10.5 and sold. He spent 188 ETH on the three and got 32.5 back. On November 9, he sold six more in just 15 hours. Another blogger tallied up his holdings: he still had 196 in May, but now he’s down to 89. He’s offloaded 107 in six months. What’s he doing with the money? Opening leveraged long positions on ETH on Hyperliquid.
This isn’t “the floor is holding.” It’s the biggest holder steadily selling off near the floor price—and he’d rather trade his monkeys for leveraged positions. The person with the most influence in the whole community has voted with his feet, and the community is celebrating that “every monkey has found a buyer.”
Of course it’s easy to find buyers when you’re selling at one-tenth of the original price. The floor holding at around 5.7 ETH is because most of what he’s selling are high-priced monkeys with rare traits. He’s hammering the premiums, not the floor. Once the premiums are gone, the floor will eventually be repriced too.
Some people also say it’s a good thing that he’s selling his monkeys because a more distributed supply is healthier. Sure—but the supply is being redistributed from a whale leaving at a loss to a bunch of newcomers catching the falling knife. I don’t see how that’s “healthy.”
The biggest problem with NFTs has never been a lack of buyers. It’s that early whales paid one-tenth of what you paid, and when they leave at a loss, you can’t even catch them on the way out.