The Senate passed the DEATH BETS Act by voice vote, and the headlines are all saying, “Prediction markets can’t bet on war and death anymore.” After reading the original text, my feeling is that this law is aimed with remarkable precision—so precise that it manages to steer right around where the most money is.
First, the facts. S.4035, introduced by Schiff and Curtis, passed on the evening of 11/19 Eastern Time. It amends Section 5c of the Commodity Exchange Act, and applies to “registered entities”—that is, exchanges and clearinghouses registered with the CFTC. It prohibits listing two types of contracts: those involving terrorism, assassination, war, “or other similar activity as determined by the CFTC”; and those involving the death of a person, or “that could reasonably be understood to be highly correlated with the death of a person.” It has only passed the Senate so far; the House hasn’t acted, and it certainly hasn’t been signed into law.
A few points that are easy to overlook:
1. Under current law, the CFTC can already ban contracts involving war, terrorism, and assassination on the grounds that they violate the public interest. This bill turns “may ban” into “must ban.” The main new provision is the one about “the death of a person.”
2. It applies to licensed exchanges. Platforms like Kalshi and the U.S. version of Polymarket, which operate within the CFTC framework, have to comply. The international version of Polymarket, which operates on-chain, serves users overseas, and blocks U.S. IP addresses, isn’t a “registered entity” as defined here, so this law can’t reach it. Schiff’s own argument is that “people with inside information can profit from violence and geopolitical events.” The result: regulated markets shut down, while similar markets remain on-chain, where they’re harder to regulate. The insider-trading problem is no smaller.
3. According to reports, an amendment passed alongside the bill specifies that it won’t affect ongoing sports contracts, the CFTC’s jurisdiction, or litigation over state gambling laws. Sports are the main battleground in this regulatory fight. What Congress unanimously agreed on this time was just the part no one wants to be seen opposing.
4. The CFTC gets to decide what counts as “similar activity.” On Tuesday, Schiff had just accused CFTC Chair Selig of misleading lawmakers at a Senate hearing. With the authority to interpret this provision in his hands, no one can say yet how strictly it will be enforced.
Bottom line: It’s a signal about the prediction-market sector, but the practical impact is small. The real things to watch are the lawsuits over sports contracts and whether the House slips anything else into the bill.
#预测市场 #Polymarket