Upbit’s “103.69% reserves” figure posted today looks good as a headline, but once you break it down, the cushion is pretty thin.
The data comes from a monthly inspection by BDO Seonghyun Accounting Corporation (as of 00:00 on 11/1; inspection period: 10/29 to 11/11). Wu Says reported the BTC and ETH details:
BTC: 175,634 coins held in on-chain custody, versus 175,546 coins on users’ account books—a surplus of 88 coins, or 0.05%
ETH: 2,274,776 coins held in on-chain custody, versus 2,271,613 coins on users’ account books—a surplus of 3,163 coins, or about 0.14%
For the two largest coins, the reserve cushion is below 0.2% for both. So where does the 3.69% come from? That figure is calculated by adding up all 25 coins after converting them to Korean won, and Wu Says notes that it includes the company’s own assets. When you aggregate everything, a surplus in one coin can cover a shortfall in another. A good-looking total doesn’t mean every coin is above 100%.
More importantly, there’s the scope. The monthly check covers only 25 coins. The quarterly report (as of 10/1) covered 819 coins plus Korean won deposits. At the time, Korean won deposits had 112.49% coverage, and three coins were listed as below 100%: ADD and ICZ were 100% short, while BTM was short by 19.36%. The stated reason in each case was that the network had shut down, making the coins impossible to verify on-chain. The amounts aren’t large, but they illustrate one thing: smaller coins really can be “on the books, but not on-chain,” and the monthly report doesn’t look at them at all.
Then there’s the methodology. The notice says it checked the balances in Dunamu’s self-built wallets and staking addresses, while liabilities were based on internal ledgers. The notice’s summary doesn’t mention tools like a Merkle tree that would let users verify for themselves that “my balance was included.” The accountants confirmed that “this much is in the wallets,” not that “no one is missing from the ledger.”
I’m not saying Upbit has a shortfall. Having major coins match 1:1 is already better than many exchanges. I just think figures like “103%” should be treated as a minimum standard, not a source of reassurance. If you hold smaller coins on the exchange, this monthly report basically has nothing to do with you.
#Upbit #Proof of Reserves